With the Recent loss of arguably Australias greatest ever sprinter in Black Caviar  one thing that always left me perplexed was just how little credit she got when compared to the mighty Winx- yes both horses where freaks but if im putting together a Noahs Ark of selecting only 1 horse then it has to be Black Caviar. We have seen some amazing horses over the last 30 years but for mine Black Caviar is the champion or champions and deserves to be recognised as such .

If we Compare Black Caviar and Winx, two of Australia's most iconic racehorses, I think for the layperson recency bias will kick in and they will say Winx was the best but whilst everyone is entitled to their opinion ( at least at the time of writing 😊 ) there is no doubt that Black Caviar was the superior horse in terms of facts and overall ratings that I personally do .No question both horses have left an indelible mark on the world of horse racing. However, several factors suggest that Black Caviar  should be considered the superior racehorse when looking at their careers in a particular light. These factors include

• her unbeaten record,
• her dominance over shorter distances,
• her international success,
• and the broader context of her victories over a deeper pool of opposition – (how could be forget the great Hay List who in any other generation would have been a champion .

First and foremost, Black Caviar's unbeaten record sets her apart. Throughout her career, she raced 25 times and never tasted defeat. This flawless record is rare in the world of horse racing btu when you consider she raced 25 times and had to race some high class horses then its truly remarkable , perhaps my favourite horse of all time is the great sunline and even she had to taste defeat racing in a stellar generation against the likes of Northerly, and co. The consistency and reliability that Black Caviar displayed each time she stepped onto the track were extraordinary- especially when you consider her size and constant “niggles” that where so well handled by her Team, and this level of perfection arguably elevates her above Winx, who, while incredibly successful, did lose on three occasions early in her career and it must be said got the luxury of racing a very “steady” bunch of horses during her reign- often times when most of the opposition where out and out stayers resuming.

Black Caviar's dominance in sprint races also contributes to her legacy. She specialized in races between 1,000 and 1,400 meters, where she was unbeatable. Her extraordinary speed and power in these shorter distances were unmatched, and she set a new standard for sprinters around the world- in almost all her races – she was nearly really asked to find top gear such was her dominance – despite this some of the ratings she produced where ELITE WORLD CLASS Efforts. While Winx excelled over middle distances, particularly in races from 1,600 to 2,200 meters, Black Caviar's sprinting prowess is often considered the epitome of excellence in this category.

Another factor in Black Caviar's favour is her international success. In 2012, who can forget when she travelled to the United Kingdom to compete in the Diamond Jubilee Stakes at Royal Ascot, one of the most prestigious racing events in the world. Despite suffering a muscle injury during the race and a jockey brain fade,  Black Caviar managed to win – beating a very good field at the time, showcasing her grit and determination on an international stage. This victory not only demonstrated her ability to compete against the best horses in the world and solidified her ranking as the worlds best horse  but also highlighted her versatility and resilience, traits that further bolster her claim to being the better racehorse.

In contrast, Winx, while an exceptional racehorse with 33 consecutive wins and a record four Cox Plates, primarily raced in Australia. Although she consistently defeated high-quality fields and set records that may stand for decades, she never raced internationally. Some may argue that this lack of international competition slightly diminishes her legacy compared to Black Caviar, who proved her mettle on a global stage.

Lastly, the broader context of Black Caviar's victories adds to her status. She raced during a time when sprinting races were highly competitive, and the level of opposition she faced was consistently strong. Despite this, she dominated every race she entered, often winning by significant margins in efforts that where full of Awe and WOW. The ability to maintain an unbeaten streak in such a competitive environment further underscores her greatness and is a significant reason why many consider her the superior racehorse when compared to Winx.

In conclusion, while both Black Caviar and Winx are legends in their own right, Black Caviar's unbeaten record, her dominance in sprinting,her overall ratings she was able to produce when not fully asked,  her international success, and the challenging competition she faced all contribute to the argument that she was the better racehorse and our greatest sprinter EVER. Each horse's achievements are remarkable, but Black Caviar's unique combination of attributes sets her apart in the annals of horse racing history and for me she will always be the benchmark for sprinters